Re: Economic Suicides Megathread
[quote=ddr;739353]it may be insensitive but they are the morons who agreed to that mortgage. if they cant pay it, then they either need to refinance.... oh wait.. credit card debt, again.. MORONIC or sell their house that they didnt deserve in the first place, and get an apartment or something that they can afford.
we should not reward stupidity.[/quote]
I agree, although I would point out that it probably isn't fair to lump everyone into this same group. There are people that bought more home than they could afford using loans with teaser rates, balloon payments, adjustable rates, etc., and as long as they were fully advised of what they were doing at the time they made the loan, I don't feel a lot of sympathy for them -- especially those teaser rates, where you KNOW the rate is jumping to an obnoxious number within a year. These people are engaged in a Sissyphean task, and bailing them out to keep them in their homes just prolongs the inevitable and rewards short-sightedness.
I do feel a bit more sympathy, however, for people that made perfectly reasonable economic decisions but have just been hit by this economic downturn -- lost jobs, plunging home values, etc. For these folks, the problem is more transitory in nature, and assuming the economy picks back up and jobs return, giving them a little bit of relief now could actually do some good in the long run. If you're a hard working person who can't make your mortgage payments on account of losing your job, I don't know that it does the banks, communities, or really anyone any service to toss you out on your ass as long as you're making an effort, at least for some reasonable period of time.
There is a limit to this, of course, and at some point, good intentions are no longer sufficient and you've got to foreclose on a property no matter what. The reality, however, is that foreclosing on properties hurts more than just the person losing his home. Every time a home sells for less than it should, it drives down the value of the other homes in the community -- and then the bank has to figure out a way to absorb that loss, and you better believe it will be passed back to consumers. If there's a way to forestall that temporarily by deferring payments or accepting smaller amounts in the short term, I'm all for it.