Re: Worst President Ever
[quote=CactusBeats;592131]FWIW, many historians tend to put FDR at the other end of the spectrum, behind just Washington and Lincoln. As you might have guessed, I tend to be left of center in my politics, but I have tended to agree with you 98% of the time Mariner. If I remember correctly, you said that you are conservative. I was waiting to see some difference in our politics. With this I finally found one. Just thought it was interesting to point out.
:)
Would I be correct in thinking you agreed with many of Ron Paul's policy positions? He is the one Republican with whom I agreed much.[/quote]
historians put FDR in the 'good' end without addressing the consequences of his terms. all of his 'positive' points are limited to what happened while he was in office, but is rarely ever expanded to the long-term consequences. Dare we forget is threat to pack the supreme, the authorization of internment camps for japanese americans, ad nauseum. At least Bush hasn't gone to such a length as going this route. You may agree that FRD was a good president, but you can only do so to the extent that you isolate his term from what followed as a result.
But what about Lincoln? All he did was trash the Constitution by giving his generals free reign to murder civilains, declared martial law, suspended habeas corpus, siezed privat property without compensation (railroads and telegraphs, iirc), conducted a war without congressional authorization, imprsoned thousands of [I]northern [/I]citizens wihtout trial, and imposed the lovely income tax we now have today. That's just a short list of the top of my head.
I would put jimmy carter up there as well, for his nice handiwork in Iran. You know, the stuff that preciptated the dogshit mess we're in now.
Republicans and Democrats alike share a wealth of horrible presidencies.
It's interesting to note that, although you're left-of-center, we (i being the conservative) are nearly always in step with our positions on certain topics.
There's an excellent explanation for this. But i dont' have the time to get into it just yet, and it's not the thread to do so.