HorizonForumsone horizon
Log inSign up

[ms] · Est. May 2002

Music madethis place,we just kept itgoing...

One durable person. One social graph. Many communities—and every way people speak, share, listen, write, gather and remember.

Forums / General Yakkity Yak

Metallica

45 durable postsStarted 2009-02-16Latest 2009-03-26
#1189204Post 41 of 45

Re: Metallica

Well, I saw this new AIC line-up 2 years ago live, and I can tell you that their new singer can match Layne Staley note-for-note on the old stuff.

However, he sure as hell is not as charismatic as Layne, you know, technically the guy is there, but the feeling isn´t the same, and Layne´s dark and troubled voice was like the "MVP" of Alice In Chains.

#1189452Post 42 of 45

Re: Metallica

gave this a listen today on the way home...

[youtube]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OHIEO1_0Ulo[/youtube]

oh i raged :RockOn:

#1189459Post 43 of 45

Re: Metallica

^^^thanks for posting that i was curius to how they sound now (been since late 80's early 90's since i was listening to them

musically i thought it was pretty damn good....but james's voice is horrible now. what the hell is he thinking. doesnt sound metal at all and it puts to shame the original recoridngs.

i was a huge fan back in the day... a fanatic really, and since bob rock recreated hetfields voice it just doesnt fit with the music like it did in there early days.

#1189530Post 44 of 45

Re: Metallica

if he still could sing like he did on MOP. His voice would be so screwed up by all the growl he put into his voice back then, he'd have to have voice surgery. Like Tom Keifer of Cinderella.

#1189582Post 45 of 45

Re: Metallica

what?? lol on that reasoning. phil anselmo has sung that way his whole life and he sounds the same as he did bak in the 80's hell james sang that way for over 10 years with no issues. has notghin to do with it. bob rock taught him how to sing in key and he sounds like crap now....

that kind of music needs a rough around the edge voice

Log in to reply