HorizonForumsone horizon
Log inSign up

[ms] · Est. May 2002

Music madethis place,we just kept itgoing...

One durable person. One social graph. Many communities—and every way people speak, share, listen, write, gather and remember.

Forums / General Yakkity Yak

Rolling Stone creates Top 30 greatest "EDM" albums - I'm sure you will agree

14 durable postsStarted 2012-08-08Latest 2012-08-14
#121543Post 1 of 14

[url="http://www.youredm.com/2012/08/07/rolling-stone-ranks-top-30-all-time-best-edm-album/"]Rolling Stone Ranks Top 30 All-Time Best EDM Albums - Your EDM[/url]

[url="http://www.rollingstone.com/music/lists/the-30-greatest-edm-albums-of-all-time-20120802?stop_mobi=yes"]The 30 Greatest EDM Albums of All Time | Rolling Stone[/url]

Perhaps the biggest publication in the music world, it seems to be a bit odd that [B]Rolling Stone [/B]would cover EDM–after all, even despite its growing popularity, it’s still a fringe genre. Regardless, [B]Rolling Stone [/B]is still desperate to prove its relevancy in a world where print publication is no longer nearly as profitable as it once was. So, now we have [B]Rolling Stone[/B]‘s ranking of the top 30 EDM albums of all time–it includes many heavyweights like [B]deadmau5[/B], [B]The Orb, [url="http://www.mercuryserver.com/forums/djdb.php?id=846"]Orbital[/url], [url="http://www.mercuryserver.com/forums/djdb.php?id=5"]Sasha[/url] & [url="http://www.mercuryserver.com/forums/djdb.php?id=2"]John Digweed[/url], Justice, [url="http://www.mercuryserver.com/forums/djdb.php?id=154"]Paul Oakenfold[/url], Aphex Twin, [url="http://www.mercuryserver.com/forums/djdb.php?id=449"]Fatboy Slim[/url], [url="http://www.mercuryserver.com/forums/djdb.php?id=1726"]Skrillex[/url], [url="http://www.mercuryserver.com/forums/djdb.php?id=324"]Burial[/url], Kraftwerk, [url="http://www.mercuryserver.com/forums/djdb.php?id=1394"]The Prodigy[/url], [/B]and [B]The Chemical Brothers[/B].

While I applaud the magazine’s effort to dig through hundreds of thousands of incredible albums to find the top 30, several of their selections are quite a bit off: historically, [B]Rolling Stone[/B]‘s focus is on what readers will find most interesting–it’s focused on popularity rather than quality. [B]Random Album Title [/B]was a much more sensical choice for a [B]deadmau5 [/B]selection than [B]4×4=12[/B], and it’s hard to really characterize [B]Madonna[/B], [B]LCD Soundsystem[/B], and [B]Moby [/B]as ‘EDM’ in the same way many of the other musicians on the list are–they come from directions like pop, indie and rock rather than the disco and funk roots of more pure dance acts. I don’t even think I have to mention the inclusion of [B]Skrillex[/B]–his music is an affront to the senses, and simply violates dance music as a whole. Let us know what you think of the list in the comment box below.

[B]The List:[/B]

[LIST=1] []Daft Punk, ‘Homework’ (Virgin, 1997) []The Chemical Brothers, ‘Dig Your Own Hole’ (Astralwerks, 1997) []Juan Atkins, ’20 Years Metroplex: 1985-2005′ (Tresor, 2005) []Carl Craig, ‘Sessions’ (K7, 2008) []Moby, ‘Play’ (V2, 1999) []2 Many DJs, ‘As Heard on Radio Soulwax Vol. 2′ (PIAS, 2002) []Various Artists, ‘Trax Records: The 20th Anniversary Collection’ (Casablanca Trax, 2004) []Daft Punk, ‘Discovery’ (Virgin, 2001) []The Prodigy, ‘Music for the Jilted Generation’ (XL, 1994) []Kraftwerk, ‘Computer World’ (Warner Bros., 1981) []Burial, ‘Untrue’ (Hyperdub, 2007) []Various Artis, ‘True Spirit, Vol. 1′ (Tressor, 2010) []Basement Jaxx, ‘Remedy’ (Astralwerks, 1999) []Skrillex, ‘Bangarang’ EP (Big Beat/Atlantic, 2011) []Fatboy Slim, ‘You’ve Come A Long Way, Baby’ (Astralwerks, 1998) []Various Artists, ‘Journey Into Paradise: The [url="http://www.mercuryserver.com/forums/djdb.php?id=1138"]Larry Levan[/url] Story’ (2006) []Aphex Twix, ‘The Richard D. James Album’ (Warp, 1996) []Michael Mayer, ‘Immer’ (Kompakt, 2002) []Underworld, ‘Anthology, 1992 – 2002′ (JBO/V2, 2003) []Avalanches, ‘Since I left You’ (Modular, 2001) []Madonna, ‘Ray of Light’ (Maverick, 1998) []LCD Soundsystem, ‘Sound of Silver’ (Capitol/EMI, 2007) []Paul Oakenfold, ‘Tranceport’ ([url="http://www.mercuryserver.com/forums/djdb.php?id=336"]Kinetic[/url], 1998) []Justice, ‘+’ (Ed Banger, 2007) []Sasha & [url="http://www.mercuryserver.com/forums/djdb.php?id=2"]John Digweed[/url], ‘Northern Exposure’ (Ultra, 1997) []4 Hero & [url="http://www.mercuryserver.com/forums/djdb.php?id=1399"]DJ Marky[/url], ‘Kings of Drum + Bass’ (BBE, 2010) []Orbital, ’20′ (Rhino, 2009) []The Orb, ‘The BBC Sessions 1991-2001′ (Island, 2008) []Deadmau5, ’4×4=12′ (Ultra Math, 2011) []Various Artists, ‘Make ‘Em Mokum Crazy’ (Mokum, 1996) [/LIST]

#1633934Post 2 of 14

Re: Rolling Stone creates Top 30 greatest "EDM" albums - I'm sure you will agree

[QUOTE=Huggie Smiles;1054212][URL="http://www.youredm.com/2012/08/07/rolling-stone-ranks-top-30-all-time-best-edm-album/"]Rolling Stone Ranks Top 30 All-Time Best EDM Albums - Your EDM[/URL]

[URL="http://www.rollingstone.com/music/lists/the-30-greatest-edm-albums-of-all-time-20120802?stop_mobi=yes"]The 30 Greatest EDM Albums of All Time | Rolling Stone[/URL]

Perhaps the biggest publication in the music world, it seems to be a bit odd that [B]Rolling Stone [/B]would cover EDM–after all, even despite its growing popularity, it’s still a fringe genre. Regardless, [B]Rolling Stone [/B]is still desperate to prove its relevancy in a world where print publication is no longer nearly as profitable as it once was. So, now we have [B]Rolling Stone[/B]‘s ranking of the top 30 EDM albums of all time–it includes many heavyweights like [B]deadmau5[/B], [B]The Orb, [URL="http://www.mercuryserver.com/forums/djdb.php?id=846"]Orbital[/URL], [URL="http://www.mercuryserver.com/forums/djdb.php?id=5"]Sasha[/URL] & [URL="http://www.mercuryserver.com/forums/djdb.php?id=2"]John Digweed[/URL], Justice, [URL="http://www.mercuryserver.com/forums/djdb.php?id=154"]Paul Oakenfold[/URL], Aphex Twin, [URL="http://www.mercuryserver.com/forums/djdb.php?id=449"]Fatboy Slim[/URL], [URL="http://www.mercuryserver.com/forums/djdb.php?id=1726"]Skrillex[/URL], [URL="http://www.mercuryserver.com/forums/djdb.php?id=324"]Burial[/URL], Kraftwerk, [URL="http://www.mercuryserver.com/forums/djdb.php?id=1394"]The Prodigy[/URL], [/B]and [B]The Chemical Brothers[/B].

While I applaud the magazine’s effort to dig through hundreds of thousands of incredible albums to find the top 30, several of their selections are quite a bit off: historically, [B]Rolling Stone[/B]‘s focus is on what readers will find most interesting–it’s focused on popularity rather than quality. [B]Random Album Title [/B]was a much more sensical choice for a [B]deadmau5 [/B]selection than [B]4×4=12[/B], and it’s hard to really characterize [B]Madonna[/B], [B]LCD Soundsystem[/B], and [B]Moby [/B]as ‘EDM’ in the same way many of the other musicians on the list are–they come from directions like pop, indie and rock rather than the disco and funk roots of more pure dance acts. I don’t even think I have to mention the inclusion of [B]Skrillex[/B]–his music is an affront to the senses, and simply violates dance music as a whole. Let us know what you think of the list in the comment box below.

[B]The List:[/B]

[LIST=1] []Daft Punk, ‘Homework’ (Virgin, 1997) []The Chemical Brothers, ‘Dig Your Own Hole’ (Astralwerks, 1997) []Juan Atkins, ’20 Years Metroplex: 1985-2005′ (Tresor, 2005) []Carl Craig, ‘Sessions’ (K7, 2008) []Moby, ‘Play’ (V2, 1999) []2 Many DJs, ‘As Heard on Radio Soulwax Vol. 2′ (PIAS, 2002) []Various Artists, ‘Trax Records: The 20th Anniversary Collection’ (Casablanca Trax, 2004) []Daft Punk, ‘Discovery’ (Virgin, 2001) []The Prodigy, ‘Music for the Jilted Generation’ (XL, 1994) []Kraftwerk, ‘Computer World’ (Warner Bros., 1981) []Burial, ‘Untrue’ (Hyperdub, 2007) []Various Artis, ‘True Spirit, Vol. 1′ (Tressor, 2010) []Basement Jaxx, ‘Remedy’ (Astralwerks, 1999) []Skrillex, ‘Bangarang’ EP (Big Beat/Atlantic, 2011) []Fatboy Slim, ‘You’ve Come A Long Way, Baby’ (Astralwerks, 1998) []Various Artists, ‘Journey Into Paradise: The [URL="http://www.mercuryserver.com/forums/djdb.php?id=1138"]Larry Levan[/URL] Story’ (2006) []Aphex Twix, ‘The Richard D. James Album’ (Warp, 1996) []Michael Mayer, ‘Immer’ (Kompakt, 2002) []Underworld, ‘Anthology, 1992 – 2002′ (JBO/V2, 2003) []Avalanches, ‘Since I left You’ (Modular, 2001) []Madonna, ‘Ray of Light’ (Maverick, 1998) []LCD Soundsystem, ‘Sound of Silver’ (Capitol/EMI, 2007) []Paul Oakenfold, ‘Tranceport’ ([URL="http://www.mercuryserver.com/forums/djdb.php?id=336"]Kinetic[/URL], 1998) []Justice, ‘+’ (Ed Banger, 2007) []Sasha & [URL="http://www.mercuryserver.com/forums/djdb.php?id=2"]John Digweed[/URL], ‘Northern Exposure’ (Ultra, 1997) []4 Hero & [URL="http://www.mercuryserver.com/forums/djdb.php?id=1399"]DJ Marky[/URL], ‘Kings of Drum + Bass’ (BBE, 2010) []Orbital, ’20′ (Rhino, 2009) []The Orb, ‘The BBC Sessions 1991-2001′ (Island, 2008) []Deadmau5, ’4×4=12′ (Ultra Math, 2011) []Various Artists, ‘Make ‘Em Mokum Crazy’ (Mokum, 1996) [/LIST] [/QUOTE] [img]http://i987.photobucket.com/albums/ae351/Saldana23/zzxz.gif[/img]

#1633935Post 3 of 14

Re: Rolling Stone creates Top 30 greatest "EDM" albums - I'm sure you will agree

[IMG]http://www.gifflix.com/files/f5541bc274e0.gif[/IMG]

#1633945Post 4 of 14

Re: Rolling Stone creates Top 30 greatest "EDM" albums - I'm sure you will agree

nb4 "wtf is edm" [IMG]http://i.imgur.com/0b9s0.gif[/IMG]

#1633949Post 5 of 14

Re: Rolling Stone creates Top 30 greatest "EDM" albums - I'm sure you will agree

[IMG]http://images.yuku.com.s3.amazonaws.com/image/gif/1f735b2d414e6d4fea48c83eac6ad246bdf5b27.gif[/IMG]

#1633953Post 6 of 14

Re: Rolling Stone creates Top 30 greatest "EDM" albums - I'm sure you will agree

has anyone here heard: Skrillex, ‘Bangarang’ EP (Big Beat/Atlantic, 2011)?

i dont hate all dubstep but havent heard any skrillex

#1633955Post 7 of 14

Re: Rolling Stone creates Top 30 greatest "EDM" albums - I'm sure you will agree

did not realize Northern Exposure was an album. That right there destroys the cred of this list. Or tranceport, etc...

Would have ranked Play and would not have ranked Discovery. Would not have ranked Skrillex or 4x4.

Also, Madonna 'Ray of Light'? notsureifserious.gov

you can probably move around a few of those and you know, so what. but there are a few that dont belong on there imho. no Goldie or Adam F? WOuld have put them on there, maybe high contrast too. I'd have put Involver on there as well, since that changed a lot. But yeah. Anyways. My two pennies.

#1633957Post 8 of 14

Re: Rolling Stone creates Top 30 greatest "EDM" albums - I'm sure you will agree

[QUOTE=floridaorange;1054240]has anyone here heard: Skrillex, ‘Bangarang’ EP (Big Beat/Atlantic, 2011)?

i dont hate all dubstep but havent heard any skrillex[/QUOTE] .. and its ahead of immer, must be phenomenal.

And where is [IMG]http://ecx.images-amazon.com/images/I/51%2B4LNG2j1L.SS500.jpg[/IMG]

?

top 3 out of that list for me are

  1. Northern Exposure
  2. Immer
  3. Play
#1633959Post 9 of 14

Re: Rolling Stone creates Top 30 greatest "EDM" albums - I'm sure you will agree

yup very contradicting list, i think the bad in it ruined it.

madonna? seriously and skrillex!!, how can u put this with burial and immer and its aphex twiN not twiX

#1634031Post 10 of 14

Re: Rolling Stone creates Top 30 greatest "EDM" albums - I'm sure you will agree

Compilations and dj mixes don't belong in a "greatest edm albums" list.

Then again, it's just Rolling Stone.

#1634292Post 11 of 14

Re: Rolling Stone creates Top 30 greatest "EDM" albums - I'm sure you will agree

There is so many albums on this list that shouldn't even been there. Since when is Madonna EDM?? Skillet, Skilsaw...whatever the guys name is sucks. I wouldn't even consider it dubstep! It's a bunch of awful, screeching sounds put together.

#1634376Post 12 of 14

Re: Rolling Stone creates Top 30 greatest "EDM" albums - I'm sure you will agree

LOL @ Rolling Stone for making a sad best of EDM list just to include their two retarded monsters of the day.

The intern who made that list just gave the genre a look on Allmusic and similar. Anyway, just a lame excuse. And death to the "American Rave Scene" led by Avicii and DJ Fuck5ace. Losers. You have the Burning Man, you had Twilo. Fucking morons.

[IMG]http://i31.photobucket.com/albums/c354/sbando/483264_338949302853069_1730268392_n.jpg[/IMG]

#1634513Post 13 of 14

Re: Rolling Stone creates Top 30 greatest "EDM" albums - I'm sure you will agree

^:shock: dude take it easy, it's just a list of music :lol:

#1634545Post 14 of 14

Re: Rolling Stone creates Top 30 greatest "EDM" albums - I'm sure you will agree

Death! Pox!

Log in to reply